Currently, mainstream biomass gasifiers can be broadly categorized into fixed-bed gasifiers and fluidized-bed gasifiers. Fluidized-bed gasifiers are further divided into circulating fluidized beds (CFB) and bubbling fluidized beds (BFB). So, what are the differences between CFB and BFB, and what are their respective characteristics? This article aims to provide concise answers to these questions.
The design of biomass fluidized-bed gasifiers is derived from coal gasifiers, operating on the same principles. The fluidized-bed technology used in coal gasification, in turn, originates from the principles of fluidized-bed combustion, which are foundational to the design of fluidized-bed boilers. The concept of the fluidized bed was introduced to distinguish it from the fixed bed. Essentially, however, both can refer to the same piece of equipment: a cylindrical vessel equipped with a gas distributor plate. The plate allows gas to pass through but prevents solid particles from doing so. A certain height of solid particles is placed above the distributor plate, and gas flows upward, sequentially passing through the plate and the particle bed.
When the operating gas velocity (also called superficial velocity, Ug) is lower than the minimum fluidization velocity (Umf) of the particles in the bed, the device is referred to as a fixed bed. When Ug exceeds Umf, it is referred to as a fluidized bed. The term “fluidized bed” is, in fact, a broad concept. However, in the combustion and gasification industries, the term typically refers to bubbling fluidized beds and circulating fluidized beds, which are examples of classical fluidization. In these systems, particles are not carried away by the gas, avoiding material losses.
Bubbling Fluidized Bed
The bubbling fluidized bed (BFB) is classified based on flow regime, with gas velocity as the primary distinguishing criterion. When the superficial velocity (Ug) falls between the minimum bubbling fluidization velocity (Umb) and the transition velocity to turbulent fluidization (Uc), the fluidized bed is specifically referred to as a bubbling fluidized bed, often abbreviated as BFB. A defining feature of BFB is the presence of bubbles of varying sizes within the bed, with bubble diameters smaller than the bed’s width. For professionals, the term “bubbling bed” often conjures a vivid mental image: bubbles continuously emerging within the bed, resembling the appearance of boiling water.

BFB Working Principle
When gas flows through a particle bed at a low velocity, the particles remain stationary, and the gas passes through the void spaces between the particles. At this stage, the bed remains in a fixed state. As the gas velocity increases, the gas begins to overcome the gravitational and static friction forces between particles, causing the solid particles to loosen and move, marking the “minimum fluidization state.”
With further increases in gas velocity, bubbles form within the bed and drive the particles to move and mix continuously. The bubbles rise through the bed, causing the particles to circulate vertically. At this stage, the bed behaves like a liquid, with significantly enhanced contact between the gas and particles, resulting in greatly improved heat and mass transfer efficiency.
Circulating Fluidized Bed
A circulating fluidized bed (CFB) refers to a fluidized bed operating under circulating fluidization technology. This process involves high-velocity gas flows that continuously suspend and circulate solid particles. The defining characteristic of a CFB lies in its cyclical particle movement. Structurally, a typical CFB system consists of an upward-flowing bed (riser), a separation device, a downward-flowing bed (downcomer), and a recirculation device. In terms of flow regimes, the riser and downcomer generally exhibit pneumatic conveying or fast fluidization, although under lower gas velocities, the flow may take the form of a turbulent bed.

CFB Working Principle
During the operation of a CFB, particles in the bed initially enter a fluidized state at relatively low gas velocities but do not yet achieve circulation. As the gas velocity increases, some particles are carried upward by the gas flow and enter a separation device, while heavier particles remain circulating at the bottom of the bed. The separation device, such as a cyclone separator, separates particles from the gas stream. The separated particles are then returned to the bottom of the bed through a recirculation device, creating a continuous cycle of movement.
Within the bed, particles undergo repeated processes of upward transport, separation, and recirculation. This repetitive motion enables efficient gas-solid mixing and creates optimal conditions for heat transfer, mass transfer, and chemical reactions.
Main Differences Between BFB & CFB
The most notable distinctions between bubbling fluidized beds (BFB) and circulating fluidized beds (CFB) can be summarized in the following aspects:
1. Gas-Solid Flow Behavior
In a BFB, solid particles primarily flow in a bubbling motion within the bed. As gas passes through the bed, it forms bubbles, resulting in a relatively stable fluidization state. Particle movement is largely confined to the interior of the bed, with only a small fraction of particles being carried out by the gas, which are then recovered using separation equipment.
In contrast, a CFB operates at higher gas velocities, enabling intensive mixing between gas and solid particles. The solid particles exhibit high-intensity circulation within the system, with a significant amount being carried out of the bed by the gas flow. These particles are recovered through devices like cyclone separators and recirculated back into the bed, forming a continuous loop.

2. Gas Velocity
The gas velocity in a BFB is relatively low, typically ranging from 0.3 to 1.5 m/s, sufficient to maintain the bubbling fluidization state. On the other hand, a CFB requires much higher gas velocities, typically between 3 to 10 m/s, to sustain the high-intensity circulation of particles.
3. Particle Size
BFBs rely on coarser particles, with typical particle diameters ranging from 300 to 1000 µm, to maintain a stable bed structure. Conversely, CFBs require finer particles, generally in the range of 50 to 300 µm, to facilitate rapid circulation and fluidization.
4. Application Scenarios
BFBs: Due to their simpler structure, smaller size, and lower investment and operational costs, BFB gasifiers are more suitable for small- to medium-scale applications. They are commonly used for the gasification of biomass, sludge, and other materials, offering economic and environmental benefits.
CFBs: With their efficient gas-solid mixing and capability for large-scale reactions, CFBs are ideal for complex and large-scale industrial applications. They are widely employed in coal gasification, large-scale boilers, and the production of industrial chemicals, where high reaction efficiency is critical.
